Why not ticket them all?
The city of New York has a problem. They issue placards which allow the people who have them to park basically anywhere in the city and not get a ticket. This article says there are over 78,000 or 20,000 or 10, 000 or who knows how many of them and when surveys are made, over half the people using them in an area either have fraudulent permits or they are misused. (In one case, 95% were misused.)
I have a solution – why not ticket every car in the city that is parked illegally, placard or not. Then have the people with legitimate permits come to an office and show their permit and the tickets would be absolved. One might assume that those being misused would simply pay their tickets and stop misusing them. My guess is parking enforcement would LOVE this approach.
The placard holders would complain that they don’t have time to come down and show their placards and tickets. Fine – Have certain days where someone from the citation department shows up for half a day a month in certain geographic areas so these folks could drop by and show their placard and citations. They could bring a laptop with a list of all placards issued, and who they were issued to. The person showing up would have to show a placard and a valid ID.
The city is going to receive a lot more citation revenue so they can afford to have a couple of people roaming around the city, voiding improperly issued “placard” tickets.
My guess is that after a couple of months, the problem if misused or fraudulent or Xeroxed placards would be reduced to a slow drip.